Interesting judge’s comments from the 2016 “Over the Edge” literary competition in Galway. Niamh Boyce writes:
“A word on titles, in general they were awful. Weak, with a last minute feel about them. The title allows you to direct a reader through your work. In a poem in particular, it allows you to say something that you have not said ‘in’ the poem. This does not apply to some of the winning and commended – but in general the titles were horrific. With such a high quality of writing, and such strong various voices in the entries, weak titles were a constant. They should not be an afterthought, the work deserves better, have fun, work on them. It didn’t affect my judging I might add, it’s just a general observation. “
I feel a New Year’s resolution coming on: take more time thinking about titles.
Copyright Mike Hopkins 2016